Should I just run a big carbon tank for our Davie tap water, or do I actually need to drill my granite for an RO faucet too?
The short answer: While a whole-house catalytic carbon backwashing filter effectively handles chloramines and reduces disinfection byproducts like the 20.1 ppb
By the WaterLux Editorial Team · Published 2026-10-01
Should I just run a big carbon tank for our Davie tap water, or do I actually need to drill my granite for an RO faucet too?
Last updated: October 2026 · Reviewed by WaterLux Water Treatment specialists
The short answer: While a whole-house catalytic carbon backwashing filter effectively handles chloramines and reduces disinfection byproducts like the 20.1 ppb of TTHMs found in Davie's water, it cannot reliably block dissolved inorganic metals. To address heavy metals like the 3.1 ppb of lead detected at the 90th percentile of local taps, homeowners in Broward County should pair whole-house carbon filtration with a dedicated point-of-use reverse osmosis system at the kitchen sink. This dual-system approach ensures comprehensive protection against both organic chemicals and dissolved metallic contaminants that bypass standard carbon media.
Is a whole-house carbon filter enough for Davie municipal water, or do we really need an under-sink RO system too?
Davie is served by two distinct municipal water systems. The City of Sunrise (Sawgrass plant) (PWSID FL4061408) serves 72,400 residents, while the Town of Davie Utilities (PWSID FL4060344) serves 26,000 residents using aeration, softening, membrane filtration, and chloramine disinfection. Your monthly utility bill identifies which system supplies your home.
Water travels through utility mains and residential plumbing before reaching your kitchen tap. According to 2023 public records, lead was detected at 3.1 ppb at the 90th percentile of home taps tested in the Davie system. Additionally, 2024 testing showed Total Trihalomethanes (TTHM) at 20.1 ppb and Haloacetic Acids (HAA5) at 12.5 ppb. These disinfection byproducts are created when chlorine or chloramine reacts with organic matter in the raw groundwater.
A whole-house carbon filter adsorbs organic compounds, chlorine, chloramines, and chemical byproducts like TTHMs and HAA5 at every tap. However, dissolved inorganic metals like lead and hexavalent chromium do not easily adhere to carbon media. A point-of-use reverse osmosis system utilizes a semi-permeable membrane that rejects dissolved inorganic compounds, providing filtration where you get your drinking and cooking water.
| Water Treatment Topic | Whole-House Catalytic Carbon Filter | Under-Sink Reverse Osmosis System |
|---|---|---|
| Water System Identification | City of Sunrise (Sawgrass plant) (PWSID FL4061408) serving 72,400 residents | Town of Davie Utilities (PWSID FL4060344) serving 26,000 residents using aeration, softening, membrane filtration, and chloramine |
| Disinfection Byproducts (TTHM/HAA5) | Whole-house activated carbon adsorbs organic compounds like TTHM (20.1 ppb) and HAA5 (12.5 ppb) at every tap | Under-sink reverse osmosis provides a secondary physical membrane barrier for reduction of remaining organic byproducts |
| Heavy Metals (Lead & Chromium) | Whole-house carbon does not remove dissolved heavy metals like lead (tested at 3.1 ppb at the 90th percentile) or chromium | Point-of-use reverse osmosis membranes reject up to 95-99% of dissolved inorganic metals and lead at the drinking water tap |
| Equipment Footprint & Maintenance | Single whole-house carbon tank utilizing a Clack valve with automatic backwashing and media replacement every 3 to 5 years | Under-sink RO system requiring a dedicated drinking water faucet, annual pre/post-filter changes, and membrane replacement every 2 to 3 years |
I recently got a quote for $8,900 from a franchise rep in Davie for a whole-house water treatment system, and I'm not sure if it's worth it given my water is only 19 GPG before treatment and the city's PFOS test came back at a federal limit, or the city's own value from its page.
Franchise models often bundle multiple pieces of equipment into proprietary packages with a high price tag, sometimes paired with financing plans around $189 per month. These systems often require proprietary cartridges, dealer-only service, and multi-year agreements for filter replacements, which locks you into a single provider for long-term maintenance.
An open-architecture approach allows you to select non-proprietary components tailored to your water chemistry. For example, the source water before treatment in Davie has a hardness of 19 GPG (325 mg/L), which is classified as very hard by the USGS. Instead of a proprietary bundled package, you can choose an independent water softener installation to manage hardness, paired with a chloramine water filter utilizing a Clack control valve. This setup uses industry-standard components that any licensed installer can service, protecting you from vendor lock-in.
| Feature | Proprietary Franchise Systems | Open-Architecture Systems (WaterLux) |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment Configuration | One-size-fits-all package with softener, whole-house carbon, and under-sink RO | Custom combination of specific components based on local water tests |
| Sales & Consultation Process | Multi-hour sales presentation and in-home demonstration | Straightforward equipment selection based on water chemistry and plumbing configuration |
| Pricing & Monthly Costs | Bundled financing plans often averaging $189/month | Component-based pricing with options starting from canonical floors |
| System Customization | Fixed packages with a softener, whole-house carbon filter, and under-sink RO system | Modular options using only the necessary components, such as a softener and a carbon filter |
| Sourcing & Flexibility | Single-brand proprietary parts and locked service contracts | Standardized components (Clack/Fleck valves, Big Blue housings) from multiple suppliers |
| Service & Long-Term Maintenance | Dealer-restricted service and proprietary filter replacements | Serviceable by any licensed Licensed and insured installer using non-proprietary media and standard parts |
Resolving the Granite Countertop Dilemma
Installing a point-of-use reverse osmosis system requires physical modification of kitchen surfaces. Drilling a 1/2-inch or 5/8-inch hole through granite, quartz, or marble requires specialized diamond-core drill bits and professional handling to prevent cracking or chipping. If you choose a point-of-use system to address dissolved metals, a licensed and insured installer should perform this drilling as part of the reverse osmosis installation.
If drilling your countertop is not an option, alternative configurations exist. You can route the reverse osmosis product line directly to your refrigerator's built-in water dispenser and ice maker, bypassing the need for a dedicated sink faucet entirely. Another option is a three-way kitchen faucet that replaces your existing main faucet, routing both standard tap water and filtered RO water through a single fixture with separate internal pathways.
Choosing the Right System Sizing for Your Davie Home
Proper sizing prevents filtration equipment from restricting your household's water pressure. A whole-house catalytic carbon filter typically requires a tank size of 1.5 to 2.0 cubic feet of media to handle the peak flow rates of a standard 3-to-4-bedroom home. This pairs with a Clack control valve to manage automatic backwashing cycles, which clean the media bed and maintain optimal flow.
For drinking water, an under-sink reverse osmosis system equipped with a 50 to 75 gallon-per-day membrane provides water for drinking, cooking, and ice-making. This combination balances whole-house chemical reduction with targeted filtration at the specific tap where you consume water. Whole house filtration starts From $1,595 and reverse osmosis systems start From $1,295.
Why WaterLux?
- 4.9-star rating from 110 Google reviews
- Authorized Hague Quality Water dealer and Aquaphor distributor
- Over 14 years serving South Florida families
- Expert water diagnostics — we match the right testing approach to your concern (in-home for hardness, lab-grade for contaminants)
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is the under-sink RO system really necessary for my water conditions in Davie, or is it just an add-on to increase the price?
- It is a necessary component if you want to address dissolved inorganic metals. While a whole-house carbon filter reduces organic chemicals like chloramines and TTHMs, it does not stop dissolved metals. In Davie, where lead was detected at 3.1 ppb at the 90th percentile of tested taps in 2023, an under-sink reverse osmosis system starting From $1,295 provides the physical membrane barrier needed to reject these metals at your kitchen tap. You can discuss your specific water concerns with our team by calling 754-317-0104.
- Does WaterLux offer in-home water evaluations in Davie?
- We provide professional in-home water testing and evaluations throughout Davie and Broward County. A specialist will visit your home to test your water's hardness and chlorine levels, inspect your plumbing configuration, and provide a written quote for a customized open-architecture system. To schedule your in-home water evaluation, contact us at 754-317-0104.
- How long has WaterLux been serving Broward County?
- WaterLux has been serving homeowners across Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach counties for over 14 years. As an authorized Hague Quality Water dealer and Aquaphor Exclusive Distributor, we design and install open-architecture filtration systems tailored to the unique water chemistry of South Florida.
- How do I know if the quoted price of $8,900 is fair, and are there more cost-effective alternatives?
- A quote of $8,900 is common for proprietary franchise packages that bundle multiple systems under multi-year agreements. An open-architecture alternative is much more cost-effective. At WaterLux, our water softeners start From $3,600, whole house filtration starts From $1,595, and reverse osmosis systems start From $1,295, allowing you to target your specific water issues without paying for unnecessary proprietary markups.
- What are the long-term maintenance costs for these systems?
- Open-architecture systems use non-proprietary components, which keeps maintenance costs competitive. A whole-house carbon filter requires media replacement every 3 to 5 years. Under-sink reverse osmosis systems require annual pre- and post-filter changes, with membrane replacement every 2 to 3 years. We offer professional water filtration maintenance starting From $199 to keep your equipment operating to manufacturer specifications.
Ready for Better Water?
Book your in-home water evaluation — no obligation, about 30 minutes
https://waterlux.com/blog/should-i-just-run-a-big-carbon-tank-for-our-davie-tap-water-or-do-i-ac